About Mothers First Surrogacy

Mothers First Surrogacy is a for-profit matching and consulting service built around prospective gestational surrogates. Rather than managing journeys itself, it educates and screens women who are considering surrogacy and then refers them to partner agencies. The agency says this guidance is offered to surrogates at no cost, and it describes itself as a company designed for surrogates by surrogates.

The founder and chief executive is Tonia Rivera, who is described as a two-time surrogate and a DONA-certified birth doula. The organization presents itself as a trusted advisor offering concierge-style management, and its public Facebook page is categorized as a consulting agency. It appears to be a small operation.

Because the program works through partner agencies, a surrogate's day-to-day case management, legal work, escrow and medical coordination would typically sit with the agency she is ultimately matched to. Mothers First Surrogacy's own role centers on the earlier steps: answering questions about what surrogacy involves, initial screening, and helping a candidate consider which agency to work with.

Any eligibility requirements, compensation figures and other details on file appear in the sections below.

Service model
Matching only
Egg donors
Not found

Reviews & reputation

Updated Sep 30, 2026
5.0
5 ratings
  • 5★5 5-star ratings
  • 4★0 4-star ratings
  • 3★0 3-star ratings
  • 2★0 2-star ratings
  • 1★0 1-star ratings

Combined from Google ratings.

What reviewers say

AI summary of 3 reviews · can make mistakes

Reviewers of Mothers First Surrogacy are uniformly positive. They often mention the team's depth of knowledge about the surrogacy process and describe clear, responsive communication that kept them informed and reassured.

Often praised

  • Deep knowledge of the surrogacy process
  • Clear, responsive communication

3 reviews match these filters.

  • Reviewer type not statedJul 19, 2024

    I had the pleasure of working with Tonia during my surrogacy journey, and I cannot speak highly enough about her attentiveness, care, and knowledge in the surrogacy industry. From our very first meeting, it was evident that Tonia was deeply committed to ensuring a positive and successful experience for both the intended parents and the surrogate. Tonia demonstrated exceptional attentiveness throughout the entire process. She was always available to answer any questions or concerns I had, and they made sure to keep me informed and updated at every stage. Her prompt responses and open communication created a strong sense of trust and reassurance. She is well-versed in the legal, medical, and emotional aspects of the process, and their expertise proved invaluable. Overall, I highly recommend Tonia for anyone embarking on a surrogacy journey. Their attentiveness, care, and extensive knowledge make them an exceptional professional in the surrogacy industry. Working with her was an incredibly positive experience, and I am grateful for their support throughout my surrogacy journey.

    View on Google (opens in a new tab)
  • Reviewer type not statedFeb 16, 2023

    Incredible wealth of knowledge and affective communication!

    View on Google (opens in a new tab)
  • Reviewer type not statedFeb 15, 2023

    Love how the company is made by surrogates for surrogates. I’m behind what they believe in and can provide for surrogates!! Her website is very easy to navigate as well unlike some other websites I’ve dealt with.

    View on Google (opens in a new tab)

Google reviews are shown as written and link to the original. Reviewer type is inferred from what each reviewer wrote.

For intended parents

Who they work with

  • LGBTQ+ intended parentsNot published
  • Single intended parentsNot published
  • International intended parentsNot published
  • Surrogates living outside the U.S.Not published

Costs

  • Fee structureUnclear from public information
  • Agency feeNot published — ask the agency
  • Escrow providerNot published — ask the agency
  • Typical time to matchNot published — ask the agency
Estimate your full journey cost →

For surrogates

Base compensation

Not published — ask the agency

Requirements

  • Age rangeNot published — ask the agency
  • Maximum BMINot published — ask the agency
  • Prior pregnanciesNot published — ask the agency
  • Prior C-sectionsNot published — ask the agency
  • Raising own childNot published — ask the agency
  • SmokingNot published — ask the agency
  • Citizenship or residencyNot published — ask the agency
  • States not acceptedNot published — ask the agency
  • Support personNot published — ask the agency

Requirements change — confirm with the agency before applying.

See which agencies fit you

Contact