Find my agency
Find my agency
Full-service

Choice Surrogacy

Wimberley, TXFounded 2015

4.620 ratings · 21 reviews across 2 sources, out of 5 stars. Jump to reviews.

About Choice Surrogacy

Choice Surrogacy, Inc., which operates as Choice Surrogacy, is a for-profit, full-service surrogacy agency founded in 2015 and headquartered in Wimberley, Texas, in the Hill Country near Austin. It describes itself as family owned and operated: Trish Taylor is listed as owner and director, her daughter Chloe joined the agency as program manager in 2019, and her son Junah came on in 2021. The company remains active and has not changed ownership.

According to the agency, it works with surrogates across the United States and with intended parents worldwide. It serves LGBTQ+ and international intended parents, and as a full-service agency it coordinates the pieces of a journey in one place rather than handling matching alone, with the agency's own program pricing presented as all-inclusive. The agency says it maintains no waitlists and charges no upfront fees.

On its marketing materials the agency reports a 97.5 percent success rate on first-time embryo transfers and a 99 percent match rate on the first profile presented to intended parents; these are the agency's own figures. Its website publishes program pricing, and the eligibility requirements it sets for surrogates, along with compensation ranges and other details, appear in the tables further down this page.

Choice Surrogacy is not accredited by the Better Business Bureau but holds an A+ rating from the BBB, whose profile lists the business as operating for eight years. Client contact is typically with the Taylor family members named above, and the agency's stated focus is on supporting both sides of a match — surrogates and intended parents — through the medical, legal, and logistical stages of a gestational surrogacy arrangement.

Service model
Full-service
Founded
2015
Offices
1
Egg donors
Not found

Highlights

  • Works with LGBTQ+ and international intended parents
  • Publishes its fee structure
  • Working with families for over 10 years

Reviews & reputation

Updated Nov 2, 2026
4.6
20 ratings
  • 5★18 5-star ratings
  • 4★0 4-star ratings
  • 3★0 3-star ratings
  • 2★0 2-star ratings
  • 1★2 1-star ratings

Combined from Google ratings. Forum and Trustpilot posts are counted as reviews but don't carry a star rating.

What reviewers say

AI summary of 20 reviews · can make mistakes

Most reviewers, nearly all of them surrogates, describe a highly personal, family-like experience with close guidance at every stage, frequent check-ins, and staff who show up for key moments like transfers and deliveries. Many also praise the matching process and say they formed lasting friendships with their intended parents or surrogate. A small minority were very unhappy, describing stalled matches after clinic setbacks, disputes over payments, and going unanswered once problems arose.

Often praised

  • Personal, hands-on support from the owners
  • Strong matches and lasting surrogate-parent bonds
  • Competitive compensation and logistics handled smoothly

Worth asking about

  • Handling of stalled matches after clinic rejections
  • Payments and communication when a journey stalls

21 reviews match these filters.

  • Reviewer type not statedOct 10, 2026

    I delivered a healthy baby May 3, 2023 with Choice Surrogacy. I have since completed amazing journeys with ConceiveAbilities. Having experienced both agencies, I better understand what proper agency support should look like. I chose Choice because I lived in Texas and thought a Texas-based agency would be the best fit. I trusted the agency to guide me, protect my interests, and look out for me. I was matched with Chinese IPs who were generally very nice and loving people. However, this experience changed how I viewed surrogacy. About two weeks after the second heartbeat confirmation, the IPs texted me, “Hey don’t know if Trish told you but we just picked up our baby from Houston this past weekend so we’ve been busy.” I had no idea they had another baby on the way. I later learned I was one of three surrogates carrying for them. These IPs were in their 50s and used a donor egg. Neither the IPs nor Trish disclosed this during matching. Had I known, I would have chosen a match still waiting and praying for a baby. I was shocked and devastated. After sharing my family history, medical history, and personal life, the lack of transparency felt personal. I spoke with my attorney, cried, & sought advice in surrogacy groups because I felt my trust had been broken. I learned that although it felt like a huge breach of trust, it didn’t breach my contract and technically wasn’t my business. I expected a beautiful, personal connection with the family I was helping. Instead, it felt transactional. The IPs didn’t attend the embryo transfer, checked in occasionally & didn’t attend the birth. The father arrived to pick up the baby along with a family member the next day, that’s when I met them physically in person for the very first time, Trish came too. They had one baby while I was pregnant and another shortly after I delivered. Medical coverage was stressful. I began IVF in July and transferred in late August, but Choice hadn’t purchased a policy for me. As a military spouse with TRICARE, I’d never worried about paying for medical care. However, TRICARE isn’t surrogacy-friendly, so I needed appropriate coverage for the journey. Trish enrolled me during open enrollment in November, but coverage didn’t begin until January, leaving me without surrogacy health insurance for more than half my pregnancy. I received medical bills and delinquency notices for surrogacy-related care. I submitted bills but felt I was getting the runaround from Trish and Chloe. I was questioned about why I went to the doctor & how appointments related to surrogacy. This was frustrating because Trish and Chloe texted me the morning of appointments to remind me to be on time and request updates afterward. They knew my appointments were pregnancy-related, yet I was questioned about the bills. I sent an email including my attorney & the IPs stating I’d pursue legal action if the outstanding bills weren’t handled. My attorney never responded. My IPs apologized and offered to pay out of pocket. Receiving delinquency notices for pregnancy-related expenses was stressful. I had insurance coverage. Amani Hansen was the attorney Choice provided. Trish told me she loved working with Amani & that they have lunch together when she is in town. At the time, I didn’t understand how important independence between an agency and the surrogate’s attorney could be. I would reach out to Amani and sometimes received no reply. I genuinely wondered, “Whose side is my attorney actually on?” I never felt she was truly in my corner. Compensation payments were sometimes several days late. When I contacted my attorney about the delays, I was directed back to Trish. Although my contract said “escrow,” Trish told me there was no escrow company because she was the escrow and had up to X amount of time to issue payments, which was through Zelle or EFT. After working with ConceiveAbilities for additional journeys, I believe there are more professional and transparent ways to manage surrogate compensation. This is my personal experience with Choice Surrogacy. I would never recommend them.

    View on Google (opens in a new tab)
  • SurrogateAug 3, 2026

    My experience with Choice Surrogacy has been nothing short of incredible. From day one, Trish and Chloe guided me through every step of the journey with kindness, encouragement, and unwavering support. They checked in frequently, made themselves readily available whenever I had questions, and always made sure there wasn't a single thing I needed. What meant the most to me though was how personal the experience felt. I was never treated like just another surrogate on their list. They took the time to get to know me as an individual, genuinely cared about my well being, and celebrated each milestone alongside me and my IPs. At the same time, they fostered such a wonderful sense of community that I felt like I was part of something bigger—a family. The relationships I've built through Choice Surrogacy are something I'll always be grateful for, and I couldn't imagine having taken this journey with any other agency.

    View on Google (opens in a new tab)
  • SurrogateAug 2, 2026

    Choice Surrogacy was wonderful to work with throughout my journey. They guided me through every step of the way and were always there to answer my questions and make sure I knew what to expect. Most importantly, they matched me with an AMAZING intended mother, and I truly couldn't have asked for a better experience. Finding the right match is one of the most important parts of the surrogacy journey, and their expertise in this industry really shows. Every journey is different, but from my experience, I have no complaints. I'm grateful for the support, professionalism, and guidance I received from the Choice team, and I would absolutely recommend them to anyone considering becoming a surrogate or growing their family through surrogacy.

    View on Google (opens in a new tab)
  • SurrogateJul 9, 2026

    I just completed my first journey in may of this year and it was an incredible experience. I'm so happy I went with choice surrogacy I loved how dedicated trish and Chloe were with me during my whole process 💓 they really do support there surrogates and I felt very safe and cared for. They were so sweet to show up to my delivery and showered me with gifts I felt very taken care of. I highly recommend choice . They are diligent and are with you every step of the way . I only thought I would do one journey but I loved it so much I'm planning to do a second. The relationship i developed with my ips is amazing we are close friends now and it's truly a beautiful experience. Thank you trish and Chloe for my amazing experience i am forever grateful 💕

    View on Google (opens in a new tab)

Google reviews are shown as written and link to the original. Forum, Yelp and Trustpilot entries are our short summaries of what was posted, linked to the source. Reviewer type is inferred from what each reviewer wrote.

For intended parents

Who they work with

  • LGBTQ+ intended parentsYes
  • Single intended parentsNot published
  • International intended parentsYes
  • Surrogates living outside the U.S.No

Costs

  • Fee structurePublished by the agency
  • Agency feeNot published — ask the agency
  • Fees before a matchNone — no agency fee until you're matched, per the agency's website
  • Escrow providerNot published — ask the agency
  • Typical time to matchNot published — ask the agency
Estimate your full journey cost →

For surrogates

Base compensation

From $55,000

Published by the agency. Benefits and allowances are usually on top of this.

Requirements

  • Age range21–45
  • Maximum BMINot published — ask the agency
  • Prior pregnanciesAt least 1
  • Prior C-sectionsNot published — ask the agency
  • Raising own childNot published — ask the agency
  • SmokingMust be a non-smoker
  • Citizenship or residencyNot published — ask the agency
  • States not acceptedNot published — ask the agency
  • Support personNot published — ask the agency

Requirements change — confirm with the agency before applying.

See which agencies fit you

Common questions about Choice Surrogacy

  • Choice Surrogacy accepts gestational surrogates between 21 and 45 years old.

Contact